Mausoleum Sued for Propping Open Caskets

Friday, 20 November 2009 13:17

Mausoleums are marketed as a "clean and dry" alternative to burial. In reality, gases and fluids can build up (especially in so-called "sealer" caskets), leading sometimes to leaks or even explosions that breach the crypt. Understandably, mausoleum owners would prefer caskets be vented so the remains dehydrate. Families-whose fears are exploited and stoked by businesses that sell them a bill of goods about "clean and dry" burial products - want their dead "safely" sealed up.
Reality and consumer expectations can't be reconciled, so what's a mausoleum to do? Apparently one Kentucky mausoleum owner decided to prop open the caskets when the families weren't around. And now she's being sued:

Betty Greiman of North College Hill says what she saw in April 2005 still haunts her dreams - her mother's casket was propped open."Some of us are having nightmares thinking there are varmints crawling around in our mom's casket," Greiman said. "My daughter is just hysterical. Mother was loved, and for her final resting place to be disturbed is not right."

Greiman said she became more upset when she filed a lawsuit three years ago in Kenton Circuit Court and the former owners of Forest Lawn Memorial Park claimed the casket was opened to prevent gases from the decomposing body of her mother, Mary Harmon, from being trapped in the mausoleum and blowing up.

It is a macabre phenomenon the funeral industry calls "exploding casket syndrome," said Joshua Slocum, the executive director for the non-profit consumer education and watchdog group The Funeral Consumers Alliance. He said there are cases across the country where decomposing bodies erode caskets and fluids run out of the crypts or gases blow off the front.

Comments (7)

As a funeral director for many years, I am very familiar with problems that arise in mausoleum crypts. Occasionally there will be an explosive event, but most problems involve leakage of body fluids from caskets. In a properly constructed crypt, which would have an adequate ventilation system and drainage provisions, no problems occur IF the casket itself is not sealed.

Inside a sealed casket, temperature changes draw moisture from the body and as vapor it condenses on the lining of the casket. When the temperature cools, the moisture drops down, usually pooling around the body. That's why most sealed caskets give off the sound of swishing water when removed from a crypt.

However, if the casket is not sealed, and especially if the lid is propped open an inch or two, the moisture escapes into the crypt and is wafted away by the ventilation system (if it is working properly). Over time, the body decomposes naturally.

Few families are told about this. The mausoleum salesmen want to push the "clean and dry" concept many people have about entombment. Greedy (and sometimes just plain ignorant) funeral directors promote socalled "protective" sealed caskets as being the best type of container, when the truth is that these sealed caskets often cause these awful problems.

So, some mausoleum operators secretly prop open the casket lids to head off any problems.
Some funeral directors will just not seal the caskets. In most cases, the families are not told this little secret.

No ethical funeral director is going to tell a family that any casket (or burial vault) is going to preserve the body.

Is there a Law aganst a family member requesting the mausoleum operator to open a crypt and the casket?

Hi,

If I contact the management about these situations about mausoleums are they obligated to tell me about there entombment procedures, if my grandparents caskets are propped open is the management obligated to tell me

Joseph - I'd say they are morally obligated to tell you, but I doubt there's any specific law on that.

one way to remedy the problem is to take the rubber gasket from the bottom half of the Casket and leave the top half on and lock the bottom so the family won't notice.

Why not just install, in each casket, a pop-off valve that slowly releases gases from the casket. It appears that what goes on in the casket is inevitable unless there is a procedures that folks with money can afford; but for the day-to-day folks this might work. It won't activate for maybe months or years down the road but it might prevent casket explosion. Gaskets don't last anyway, if its a grave grass and water will get in anyway and there goes your warranty - which you won't know happened anyway. What do you think?

I have been a funeral director and embalmer for many years. Every time we have a mausoleum service I have this warm and comforting feeling. Mausoleums are the best choice and will always be the best chioce of interment. Even with the problems sometimes encountered, they provide a more dignified burial place for family to visit out of the harsh elements of weather. Think about it. Cremation is just not appealing. Ground burials are, however traditional, not in my opinion very appealing either. Lets face it kids, mausoleums are the "Six Flags of Fun" of interment. So what, if you get an occassional smell of rotting flesh, a fly in your eye, or the hint of liquid leaking down the wall. These things are only exciting reminders of the delightful future that awaits us all.
Birmingham, Alabama July 6, 2011